Info

The hedgehog was engaged in a fight with

Read More

Immigration and Crime in Italy: a Missing Link?

A boat of migrants awaits the intervention of the coast guard off Lampedusa, Italy, 31 August 2021. (Juan Medina, Reuters/Contrasto)

Immigration is an articulated phenomenon that has undergone profound changes over time. Nowadays, as the number of immigrants in the world continues to grow at an unprecedented rate, immigration has become one of the main topics of political, social, and economic debate. Indeed, In Italy, the relationship between immigration and crime has been a major topic in public opinion, the media, and election campaigns, with some candidates claiming that the influx of people into the nation during the immigration crisis has increased the danger of crime. Is it true, however, that immigration has increased crime in Italy? Or is this perception fueled by the media?

Why do the media narrate the immigrant’s crime?

A structural fact that distinguishes Italian television information is the component of insecurity deriving from the reporting of crime. Crime has placed second or third on the news’ overall thematic agenda in recent years, giving the impression that we are being overwhelmed by a wave of unprecedented violence brought by immigrants. 

This is what mostly emerges from research conducted in the years 2005-2008 on the major Italian newspapers: “Corriere Della Sera,” “Il Giornale,” and “la Repubblica.” Even when stories are not immediately focused on their delicts, immigrants are primarily referred of in terms of conflict and issues, according to the research. The constant themes are the combination of foreign crime, the social danger of immigrants, control, justice, and penal measures.

Most academics believe that the migration emergency was built at the political and media level, with immigrants being labeled as criminals. Surely, the media’s role in Italy, which catches Italians’ fears and never misses an opportunity to feed the reader his favorite subject, exacerbates the politics of fear. An article about an immigrant committing a crime will almost always catch the public’s curiosity more than one about an Italian doing the same crime. The media’s attention on certain subjects clearly contributes to immigrant anxiety.

Several scholars argue that TV news and press, also tend to emphasize the nationality of immigrants in the news story, while in the case of natives is usually expressed only sex and age. Identifying foreigners primarily through nationality is a harmful habit that stimulates dangerous stereotypes, slowing down integrative processes. Categorizing foreigners according to citizenship, favors the creation of an “us” and “them”, raising walls instead of tearing them down. Often what the news broadcasts, in combination with the tone with which they are told, feed feelings of hatred and repression: boats full of people are perceived too often as an invasion rather than arouse feelings of solidarity.

Indeed, it appears that campaigning on the imagined relationship between immigration and insecurity is the glue that holds the far-right and center-right alliance together. This informative TED talk can provide additional information regarding the criminalization of migrants as a political strategy that is currently widespread.

Has immigration really led to an increase in crime in Italy?

Considering how the Italian news is presented in the media every day, it may seem that we are overwhelmed by a wave of extraordinary violence brought by immigrants.  If it were true that Italy is becoming more and more insecure, as claimed by the public opinion and the media, we would expect to find increasing crime rates. However, the literature is rather unanimous in stating that statistics on the number of crimes committed throughout Italy has fallen, both in the economically stronger northern regions and in the crisis-ridden southern regions.

Undoubtedly, Italy is one of the countries where immigrants are welcomed with the most hostility. In a poll conducted by the European Union in 2017, which asked people whether immigrants make their country a better or worse place to live, immigration was considered as a source of concern for 36 percent of Italian respondents. Surely, many Italians believe that crime has increased, linking this supposed increase to the increase of immigrants in the country. This is a perception that is not reflected in the data, since crime is decreasing despite the significant increase in foreign presence in Italy. Between 2007 and 2016, crime rates per 1,000 people in Italy declined by about 25% on average across all regions. Even when we look at the variance of crimes committed within regions, we see a downward tendency.

Nonetheless, in contrast to general crime rates in Italy, the proportion of crimes committed by foreigners is falling in every area of the country when compared to the regional average. Between 2007 and 2016, the average area crime rate among immigrants fell by roughly 65 percent. Today, the percentage of foreigners convicted is at an all-time low.

Can we solve this misconception?

Cartoon by Mauro Biani, saying “Never forget: immigrants=criminality”
Author: Mauro Biani

Based on the research I conducted for this blog, there is a missing link between the growth of immigration in Italy and the rise in crime rates.

We would make significant progress if the media took on the responsibility of communicating real information rather than acting as loudspeakers for representations that are frequently just good for a symbolic policy of increased criminalization with little impact. This would be crucial to prevent distrust and misperceptions of the immigrants. Indeed, there is still much debate among scholars.

9 thoughts on “Immigration and Crime in Italy: a Missing Link?”

  1. Hello, I found this blog post quite interesting as there was many valid points which were mentioned. I enjoyed the cartoon image that was included as it made me think. However, you mention that the media contribute to migrant anxiety, what do you mean by this?
    Grace

    1. Hello, Grace:) I’m glad you found my post fascinating; I feel this issue is really relevant nowadays! Thank you for posing the question as well. When I argue that the media contributes to immigration anxiety, I mean that the media is a fundamental tool for citizens to develop and express their ideas nowadays. As a result, if the media portrays immigrants as criminals, the public is conditioned to believe the same. If you wish to learn more about this topic, visit https://www.dahrendorf-forum.eu/narratives-around-migration-online-anxiety-over-facts/. Please do not hesitate to contact me if you have any more questions.

  2. Hi!
    I really enjoyed your blog, well done.
    I was wondering, what types of immigrants are you talking about? Moreover, has the literature you found suggested practical ways to reduce these xenophobic behaviours?
    Elena

  3. Hello, Elena! Thank you for taking the time to read my post and leave a comment.
    I’m referring to the immigration phenomenon in general rather than a specific sort of immigrant in this post because I’m attempting to get a larger sense of how immigrants (of all kinds) are regarded and portrayed in Italy. Indeed, the literature cited in my post indicates some practical approaches to reducing these xenophobic attitudes. Several scholars, for example, say that the media should be pushed to take constructive action in order to erase stereotypes, avoid fueling racism, and avoid sensationalist reporting. If you wish to learn more about this issue, I can recommend you to read this article: https://fra.europa.eu/sites/default/files/fra uploads/153-euromed en.pdf

  4. Hi! Your topic is very interesting! I was part of the people who believed that there was a relationship between crime and immigration. Your blog changed my mind.
    I think you are going in a good direction. I totally agree that the media has a vital responsibility in the diffusion of objective news instead of transmitting news according to the political party they support.
    Good luck! Hope that you find good pictures you can add to your blog!

  5. Hello and thank you for your feedback. I’m happy to hear you’ve changed your mind on the connection between immigration and crime! Hopefully, with the addition of the image, the blog will be more enjoyable to read now.

  6. Hey! I found your article super interesting, you mentioned so many important factors that make the public opinion distorted. I like the fact that you talked about the news papers’ responsability, and the fact that those you mentioned are usually seen as “left wing” news papers, but they still portrait migrants in a negative way. However, I also noticed that the data about crime are only up to 2016, it would have been interesting to find some statistics about the later years to see if the integration process worked and how the crime rate changed. But overall you made a really clear blog with good and interesting points. Good job.

  7. Hi! I found your blog very interesting and it was easy to read. It is still an hot topic, not only in Italy but in all of Europe. Do you think that Brussels should get more involved in this topic and that this problem will be easier solved on a European level instead of a national one?

    1. Hello and thank you for your comment:) Certainly, Brussels should become more engaged since this is an essential problem not just at the national but also at the European level. I believe that the EU, along with its member states, should foster stability, education, and work opportunities in order to lower crime rates committed by immigrants even more.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *