Info

The hedgehog was engaged in a fight with

Read More

Immigrants’ contribution to the healthcare system

Why is this topic not researched more? – Anna

The far-right wing in Italy has put an emphasis on the negative impact that immigration has had on the country. From crime rate to the football field, it has a general impact on natives’ perception. Over the past 10 years, Italy’s migration rate has fluctuated, from a high percentage then a slow decrease and now, faces a raise in the number of immigrants once again. These fluctuations have impacted the way that Italy has seen and integrated immigrants in their country. Although refugees are more talked about, there is an great number of legal immigrants who also may have been impacted by Italian decision making and systems in general. Immigrants have impacted health systems within the country. If they have impacted the health systems in a negative or positive way, this has been a source of controversy.

Financial contribution – why is that?

Researchers have often concluded that when it comes to immigrant’s health status, the results are contradictory. It is not a question that the majority of natives in Italy believe that migrants are not only putting a financial burden on the public health systems, but are also stealing natives’ jobs. Although this has been a general perception among Italian citizens, it has been proven otherwise through their contributions to the public finances by paying taxes. Health systems have not changed considerably, thus making it harder for immigrants to access it. Nonetheless, once using the care provided, it has only shown its benefits. Immigrants are impacting, even today, both sides of the health systems as care workers and patients.

A 1% increase in legal immigrants for the total population of Italy has resulted in a decrease around 4% in public health expenditure, which does not compromise the goals or the health systems in Italy. There are some reasons that explain this effect. One of them being ‘the healthy immigrant effect’ which proves that immigrants in general are in better health and are younger than natives Italians. As foreigners, they have a lack of knowledge about the health system and have trouble communicating with health care professionals. This results in them choosing to seek professional help only as a last resort. As they are most likely healthy, they do not need to use any particular services except, perhaps the maternity services or services related to reproductive health. In this regard, the expenses from the healthcare systems have not been major.

Are immigrants an intercultural asset?

Immigrants can only be beneficial to the healthcare system through the model of intercultural approach. This intercultural approach is based on three aspects. Firstly, the interaction and relation of a foreign person and a health care operator. Secondly, constructive criticism is needed for communication to be more effective and to improve the professional help that the patient requires. Thirdly, a rise in language and cultural exchange to ease the relationship. This model can only be achieved through a growth in the professional competences by bringing awareness of the different health needs of people with different cultures. Additionally, it increases the effectiveness of the health systems by having more enriched staff and resources for health care promotion in the community.

Photo by Matthias Zomer from Pexels

How are they helping us and society?

As care workers are concerned, most European countries with an ageing population need migrant health care workers. Although there has been an increase of immigrant healthcare recognition, more recognition is needed socially and from the government. In Italy, not much effort was made to improve its system of care. Traditionally, it was a family’s responsibility to take care of their elderly, however, it is more and more difficult nowadays. Therefore, most of time when the family cannot provide care themselves, they go to a private provider. As such, Italy’s system is no longer a family dependent system. They are reliant on migrant care givers making it a migrant dependent system. It can be said that the majority of care workers are nurses who are employed in formal eldercare are migrants. Not only are migrants responding to the ongoing demand of healthcare workers and care services, but they are also taking jobs Italian people have left vacant.

Immigrants in a country are more often at a reproductive age. Thus, they are more likely to use maternity and reproductive health related services than any other health care services. In other situations, immigrants tend to go to the emergency room rather than primary care because of difficulties with health care accessibility. Without recognition, it is hard to integrate them and benefit from their intercultural expertise. Legal immigrant workers are skilled and contribute to the health systems mostly as nurses and care workers for elderly. By doing so they are only an asset to society the economy of the country. They are filling in vacant jobs, contributing to the GDP of the country, and decreasing health expenditure because they are less likely to use healthcare because of the ‘healthy immigrant effect.’ As a result, it is best to improve the healthcare system so that everybody can benefit from it.

Anna, 20, Romania

As an immigrant myself in the Netherlands, I had difficulties with understanding and getting proper care in the Dutch health care system. Thus my interest to research within the topic – Anna


9 thoughts on “Immigrants’ contribution to the healthcare system”

  1. Hey there,
    I also think that this topic deserves to be researched more, therefore I enjoyed reading more about it, although I did spot some small language mistakes here and there.
    What I would like to know more about concerns the opinion of the general Italian public towards having immigrant healthcare workers taking care of them. Do you think that the Italian negative perception of immigrants also translates into Italy’s healthcare system?
    Would love to hear more about this.
    – Kalina

  2. Hi!
    Really interesting topic, and I also agree that as an immigrant in the Netherlands, understanding their system is confusing.
    I was wondering if the Covid-19 pandemic has affected the access immigrants have to the healthcare system in Italy? For legal and undocumented immigrants.
    On another note, from the structure I am not sure if you’re missing hyperlinks in the last section?
    Elena

    1. Hi Elena!
      Thank you for your question and the remark made! I will soon add more hyperlinks!
      As for your question, while there hasn’t been sufficient research to create a concrete argument for legal immigrants, the entire population in Italy, including legal immigrants, has faced limitations in accessing healthcare during the first months of the pandemic. However, a research has shown, that undocumented immigrants had no access to the national health system through emergency departments, other NGOs or any other healthcare assistance. Additionally, there has been a lack of government preventive information campaigns or public health measures promotions in regard to undocumented immigrants.
      Here is the link of the research if you’re interested in reading further: https://academic.oup.com/eurpub/article/30/6/1186/5942976?login=true
      -Anna

  3. Hi Kalina!
    Thank you for your message! I believe that the negative perception of immigrants does not necessarily translate directly into the healthcare system. It is more a question of the Italian health system not being more up to date with the social changes, such as migrants. There’s a lack of evidence which shows that Italians have a negative or positive opinion on immigrant workers taking care of them. There are however Italian policies which are discriminatory to immigrants and make it difficult for them to be integrated in within the Italian society.
    -Anna

  4. Hi Anna! What an interesting topic, and I couldn’t agree more – this topic deserves so much more attention. So thanks for drawing my attention to it. Before, I did not know about the ‘healthy immigrant effect” and found it very interesting. I was wondering, is there any recognisable difference between men and women immigrants in the health care system? Like is there one gender more represented? I am curious to hear what you have to say! Hannah 🙂

    1. Hi Hannah,
      Thank you for your input! In terms of patients, researchers have found that women tend to use health services more than men because of the maternity services. As for care workers, there has been an increase in employment of migrant female workers, thus not challenging gender norms.
      To read more about the topic, here is a journal article on ‘the organization of care work in Italy: gender and migrant labour in the new economy’: https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.2979/gls.2006.13.1.207?casa_token=eNsDc-mVM_wAAAAA%3AAq6JQDSO1_7KCj2Zo3CSlRCQIeg-7PVmUBEXbrFqDxTAAuDb-73Ef-QnaI40iAxVmFcCkQKrG6ImzOBC3LtlvJyp5kfBkoVBuwIJGtWHohwKOFJhYQ#metadata_info_tab_contents
      Hope I answered your question,
      -Anna

  5. Hey Anna,

    Really liked reading your blog. I love how you introduced the topic and the importance really shows. Moreover, I like that you have defined several terms. However, you mention that immigrations are impacting on both sides of the health systems as care workers and as patients. I wonder, do you think the influence of workers will grow in the future? Also, keeping in mind the COVID pandemic.

    Rosa.

    1. Hey Rosa!
      I’m so happy to hear that, thank you for your message. Unfortunately, the topic of the influence of migrant works and the Covid-19 pandemic has not been researched yet. For now, it is hard to predict immigration trends and their impact on the migrant workers, while the pandemic is still happening. As soon as new research appears, I will come back to you with a more concrete answer.
      -Anna

  6. Hi Anna,
    I just wanted to add that I liked your blog. It’s an interesting topic that I didn’t know much about and gave me new insides. I also think your extensive reply’s to the comments shows your great knowledge about this topic.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *