The Visegrad states – United in hatred against migrants?
The 2015 refugee crisis has confronted Europe with the fundamental debate of how to deal with migrants reaching European ground. The positions could not have been more different. From Germany’s so-called ‘welcome culture’ to the xenophobic campaigns of the Hungarian government, which implemented, among other things, the construction of a border fence against refugees. In addition Poland, Slovakia and the Czech Republic also took similar positions.
The Visegrad countries, also known as ‘V4’ for short, were perceived by the public as a uniform bloc against the general consensus of the EU that solidarity must be granted to refugees in such a situation. But what characterized this uniformity? And did it come to stronger cooperation only based on an ‘anti-attitude’ towards refugees? Or do other factors also play a role? These questions will be answered in this blog entry.

In 2016, the European Commission published a paper on the establishment of a European agenda for migration. In this paper it is stated that the relationships between the Member States during the refugee crisus depend to a large extent on the ability and willingness to cooperate in migration management. This indicates that although there are agreements, it is questionable wether countries are willing to enforce measures such as quotas.
The Visegrad countries, in particular, were unwilling to go along with the EU’s proposed refugee redistribution plans. These provided for each EU member state to take in a certain number of refugees. The number was measured by factors such as population and GDP. The Visegrad states instead invoked the Schengen Agreement, which guarantees the freedom of movement of individuals. But what are the reasons that the V4 are so massively opposed to migrants and the European Union?

Where does this strong anti-immigrant attitude come from?
The strengthening of right-wing nationalist parties in all four countries can be identified as one of the main reasons. Even before the refugee crisis, discrimination against minorities, especially Sinti and Roma, paradoxically, minorities from neighbouring countries, was a popular tool of gaining votes. A threat of strangers from other continents with different religions was thus the ideal enemy image, which led to a strengthening of xenophobia.
Nationalism also plays into this as an important common factor. Viktor Orbán justified the construction of a border fence with the aim to ‘preserve Hungary to Hungarians’. At the same time as nationalism has increased, attitudes toward the EU have decreased. In many parties, the motto ‘less EU, more nation-state’ was demanded and the EU’s requirements were often ignored. The quota system was viewed very negatively in the Visegrad countries, and in Hungary, for example, a referendum was held on the subject. 98% of the participants were against a fair distribution of refugees among all EU states. Although the referendum was declared invalid, it still had a symbolic power.
Also, the cuts in press freedom and hateful language of politicians adressing refugees can be identified in all of the Visegrad countries. All these factors ultimately lead to a large part of the population adopting such positions and contribute to the uniformity of the Visegrad countries, referring to the position towards migrants.
A greater cooperation among the Visegrad countries during the refugee crisis?
Statistics show that there were more meetings of the V4 and significantly longer joint press statements. The topics of these press statements overwhelmingly revolve around migration and security policy. EU policies, on the other hand, play a minor role.
It becomes clear that the Visegrad countries can agree on common ground on questions of migration or opposition to EU measures. On the surface, this may present a unified image. However, there is no institutional demand for permanent agreement or cooperation within the group. Therefore, there is unity only on a few issues, such as migration policy, which is not given on other subjects due to too different positions.
What is the main take-away from this?
In the refugee crisis, the Visegrad countries have clearly gone against the general consensus in the EU that this crisis must be solved together. The reasons for this unwillingness to participate were different.
In particular, hatred of refugees on the part of far-right parties and politicians has led to a climate of fear. And certainly the factor that Poland, the Czech Republic, Slovakia and Hungary have among the lowest percentage of people with a migration background in the EU also plays a role. Cooperation among the Visegrad countries is essentially limited to migration issues.
Therefore, it can be stated that during the crisis, the group was able to distinguish itself only with this issue and thus gained sad notoriety. However, it will be interesting to see if in the future the Visegrad group can change its policy towards a more pro-European course and build regional cooperation in different fields, not based on hatred and fear towards other people.


Hello! I really enjoyed your post the visuals are very fitting. I really like how you developed the position of the Visegrad states. how do you think will the movement develop in the future? Will these countries still cooperate also to tackle issues as the immigrant crisis at the Polish – Belarusian border?
Hi Rebecca, Thank you for your comment! The question wether they will operate that closely again in the future is questionable. For my understanding it is highly dependent on how and by who the countries are governed. When we look at Hungary and Viktor Orbán it can be seen that he is following a clear anti-EU attitude and cares more about national issues. Next spring they have the elections where there is the possibility of a more EU-oriented government to be elected. It could also engage in effective regional cooperations such as the Visegrad movement. When looking at the situation at the Polish-Belarussian border it is likely that these four states again refuse to take in refugees. Although the situation here is slightly different, because Belarus is trying to send migrants to the EU borders on purpose in order to blackmail the EU. It remains to be seen how the four states will react to this development. However, I hardly expect solidarity from these states in the face of the current governments, especially in Hungary and Poland.