Thinking about the costs of hosting refugees.
Perspectives matter.
The discussion on the public about immigration can be misleading. When choosing which term to use for immigrants, we can determine whether we have positive or negative connotations with the topic. Immigrants are a diverse group where the word itself is not self-explanatory. Immigrants can be refugees fleeing war from their home country, economic migrants from safe countries looking for a better standard of life, or migrants who came to study or work and then decided to stay. The type of immigration used at any given time depends on the context, goals, and purpose. At its most practical, this may mean that the definition of immigrant can influence the outcome of the topic and the feelings we associate with it.
Defining the costs of hosting refugees is not straightforward. It depends on multiple factors, and this post sheds light on just two but significant points – bureaucracy and level of integration. Research on the topic is contradicting due to the different ways the available data, which is also not abundant, is being used. The short-term costs are significant for such reasons as the refugees are in an unfamiliar environment without safety nets and therefore require help settling into the usual daily routine of the new society.
Looking at the long-term costs is more meaningful since refugees had the opportunity to benefit the state. e.g. integrate into society, find a job, create a firm, pay taxes or contribute to the country with posterity. In the long-term, refugees have a higher percentage to become beneficial for the host country. In this case, refugees have a better chance to “pay back” the costs of short-term hosting. That also depends on which age the refugee arrives in the host country and whether they stay there long term.
Studies using shorter timescales find that refugees present a net cost, while those using longer timescales generally find a net contribution.
Problematic bureaucracy.
If the EU countries could speed up the asylum wait times, the costs could decrease. When asylum seekers arrive in the EU country, they are sent to the reception center to wait for the host-country to handle the bureaucratic works. However, the asylum application process is lengthy; it can take up to 665 days to get the asylum decision. Also, getting a working permit after the asylum application has been lodged differs between the EU states by 60 days in Italy to 9 months in Ireland at worst, read more.
The basic assumption is that if you are working, you are not using society’s welfare and instead benefit the country with work input. Whereas, if you are not working, well… The refugee cannot start working before getting the working permit, indicating that they rely on welfare as long as the bureaucracy takes. Studies suggest that the faster the refugees can start labor, the net costs for the host-country’s public expenditures will decrease.
Few words about the necessity of integration.
The costly and time-consuming bureaucracy on arrival lays great costs on society in the short term. Therefore, quick integration into the new community and its labor markets is essential in many aspects. Integration creates a better feeling of social belonging, and having a job or going to school helps to rhythm the days. It eventually leads to diminishing the public costs from welfare.
Long-time unemployment is expensive for the state regardless of whether the person is native or refugee, no matter how skilled they are. But quick integration into labor markets also helps refugees keep up their skills. It prevents them from the steep barriers of re-entering the labor markets after a long time of unemployment. However, refugees may struggle in the labor markets with employment due mismatch of skills. You can read more about the struggles refugees face in labor markets here.
But suppose the refugee is near retirement age or cannot enter the labor markets at any point. In that case, their economic contribution is low or even zero. And they are a burden for the host-country’s welfare expenditures (Read more).
How can we make it economically viable?
A quicker process would reduce the short-term costs created during the wait for the permits that provide tools for a more normal life. With different levels of potential, some refugees are keen to start working. All the refugees may not be ready, for instance, mentally. Therefore it would be essential to harness the keen ones as quickly as possible so the economy could gain from their migration.
Society should provide the refugees with the best possible integration tools such as language proficiency, education, support on labor markets, and with welcoming community. By creating the feeling of belonging, the society has a better chance of ensuring the new citizens’ willingness to stay long to pay back their short-term costs. Studies that focus on the short-term costs of hosting refugees show that the start is expensive, and the host-country is only losing money there. Therefore, it is crucial to ensure that the refugee stays for the long term. If the refugee decides to leave the hosting country, the refugee cannot cover the short-term costs. Therefore, well carried out integration would enhance the opportunity of remaining in the host-country.





Hello there! It was fascinating to read your post because I was unfamiliar with the majority of the topics you researched. I believe your blog’s structure is straightforward, and the data you give are understandable.
The picture you showed makes me feel uneasy about governments. I feel it reflects the government’s basic emotion when deciding whether to accept a refugee or an economic migrant. When it comes to deciding what to do with immigration, they are such hypocrites. This tweet exemplifies how inhumane our species is.
Above all, I believe your topic is quite intriguing, and you wrote properly.
Cecilia 🙂
Hi Cecilia, and thanks for the comment!
The people in the governments sometimes have to face hard choices indeed. As I tried to show at the start of the blog, the discussion about immigrants is often fuelled with emotions and misleading terminology. When we add economic insights into these two – the soup is ready. Each person views immigration differently, and this creates different outcomes in the governments as well. Only long-term surveying will show us whether our governments did right or wrong decisions.
– Sari
Hey! I really enjoyed reading your blog =). I think it’s crucial to look at this part of immigration since many people use the “cost of refugees” as an argument for stricter immigration policies. It was interesting to learn something about the bigger picture and that there is an important difference between the short-term and long-term costs. Your blog really gave me a lot of new insights!
I have one question that would interest me. Why do you think the bureaucracy is still so extensive, even though everyone knows that it is pretty costly?
Jana
Hi Jana,
Thanks for an excellent question!
One of the reasons has something to do with the size and timing of the flows (as most of the studies focus on these significant events). For example, the migration flows of 2015 to the EU were vast and unexpected. Therefore, the governments weren’t ready to handle such paperwork and other integration efficiently.
Another reason is that these migrants are asylum seekers on arrival, meaning that they yet haven’t got refugee status. Therefore they are residing illegally in the host country. When granted refugee status, they reside legally in the host country. During the waiting period for refugee status, the asylum seekers find themselves in legal and social limbo. A refugee can be described as a person who has fled their home under threat with minimal personal belongings. It may be safer/better for them not to carry any identification papers with them. When asylum seekers arrive in the promised land of bureaucracy, they cannot prove who they are, and the paperwork they fill may not be correct. And it is the government’s responsibility to check the person’s background, for example, to ensure the person is not a threat to society.
So the combination of massive flows and extensive background checks are time-consuming. As this vast migration flow is relatively new for the EU, there is no readiness to answer these loads. My answer was probably just half of the truth, as I haven’t encountered the reasons for the government’s slowness in the researches I used for this post. However, I hope it gave you some insight into the reasons for extensive bureaucracy.
– Sari
Hi! Your blog is very interesting! This is a real serious issue that the EU is facing and by reading your blog I really learn some stuffs about this topic. Before reading it I didn’t know that it can take so many time for Ireland to give a working permission.
The pictures are also very well chosen, they are very well related to the topic you are writing about. Also, I appreciate that you suggest really good ways to solve this problem.
However I have a question: Do you think the money spent by the government for hosting refugees can be used as a reason of discrimination by the citizens?
Hi rociosun,
The share of migrants in some European countries is relatively small. For example, In 2019, there were 8% of people with a foreign background of the total population in Finland. Although the refugees bore some costs in the short term, it would be essential to consider the costs of the “native” population as well.
The Finnish welfare state is based on the Nordic universal model, covering everything from baby to grandchild. And in 2021, 80% of Finns received subsidies from the government. Usually, the refugees that arrive in Europe are of working age. We could say that the host country has received a free human capital (= the skills, knowledge, and experience possessed by an individual or population, viewed in terms of their value to an organization or society) without investing in it. So, the host country has “saved” a lot of money with these refugees when the government hasn’t had to spend money on their childhood’s hospital fees, social benefits, and education.
Of course, the costs of hosting refugees are the first thing in mind when arguing against them. Still, by proportioning the short-term costs of refugees to the long-term costs of natives, there may not be a significant difference between the costs in the end. However, this idea that I presented to you may not be suitable for every country.
– Sari
hey, I found your topic very interesting. You well explained the economic benefit of migrants and how statistics can be altered if they focus on the short or long term. In the last days I read that Poland already spent 350, million euros to block migrants from Belarus and it shocked me becasue those money could be spent to help those migrants integrate in the country. Such a waste of money that does not benefit anyone. This also links to the tweet that you put, humans are much more based on stereotypes and principles than actual facts and rationality. Why do we have to differ between refugees and economic migrants? If someone decide to leave everything and escape in another country there has to be a good reason. Back to your blog, the only suggestion that I could make is that instead of using unrelated images, it would have been interesting to see some graphs maybe about government expenditure on migrant integration. But overall you did a really good job!