Info

The hedgehog was engaged in a fight with

Read More
The different aspects and steps of migration in Europe

Rise of crime in Germany by migrants?

We all have witnessed the influx of asylum seekers during Europe’s migration crisis in which thousands of migrants had tried to enter European soil via the Mediterranean coast illegally, after civil conflicts broke out in the Middle East.

Speculations, however, were raised, claiming that more migrants meant more crime. The political spectrum, as well as media discourses, may have contributed to this phenomenon which consequently led to preconceived ideas towards migrants even more.

However, it is vital for all of us to raise this crucial question! since such notions influence the future prospects of the migrant as a whole.

Having said that, I will concentrate on Germany since it became the center of attention after accepting the admission of approximately 1,400,000 refugees since 2015.

But before moving forward! I would like to give you a broader explanation of the term ‘migrant’ as there are several meanings and connotations reflected to the term.

Photo by Ahmed akacha from Pexels

Migrants are a collective group of individuals who move from their place of birth to another destination for various reasons, ranging from; economic reasons to security issues such as civil wars and political persecution.

I will concentrate on the subset of migrants, namely refugees, which are, unlike asylum seekers, considered legally protected under the 1951 Convention after their application for asylum.

Consequently, migrant and refugee will be used interchangeably throughout the blog with reference to recognized refugees.

In addition, I will focus on the sub-category of criminal crimes, namely economic crimes, as many migrants have been directly linked to such crimes through the media and political parties. As with migrants, criminal crime and economic crime will be used interchangeably throughout my blog.

Theoretical Foundations 

Several theories have been put forward by various academics and scholars on why, and under which incitements and motivations migrants would contribute to economic crimes. One of these theories suggests that regional conditions wherein these migrants are located in, do have poor labor prospects and, therefore, compels them to commit economic crimes.

Legally recognized refugees encounter language deficits, illiteracy, and general lack of knowledge, which are considered the main factors for migrants not having a decent chance in the labor market.

Can the impediment of financial support, unemployment, and regional condition only, lead to possible criminal crimes?

Other academics rested their theory on the fact that migrants are exposed by indirect spillovers, which eventually means that migrants are counter-reacting on discriminatory and violent acts by native individuals, or acts in accordance with social failure, frustration, and isolation, as poor labor market prospects confront the migrant.

This theory on indirect spillovers can have severe consequences for the migrant as the perception and observance of society concerning the migrant may change from innocent victim to perpetrator.

Social psychological theories conducted by various scholars and academics suggest that those migrants that have experienced civil wars and political prosecution are more committed to crime since political confrontations and the environment wherein they have lived influence their behavior on a socio-economic level.

The psychological theory of violence breeds violence is nevertheless contentious since it directly excludes a whole group of individuals based on their descent.

But what do reports and data tell us?

Theoretical theories told us that, regional conditions, social surroundings, and indirect spillovers, may encourage migrants to commit more crimes.

Scholars, however, have indeed shown on the basis of reports and data from Polizeiliche Kriminal and BAMF that; legally recognized refugees are more likely to live in large cities such as; Hamburg, Stuttgart, and Berlin, hoping to find job opportunities, but afterward, they get confronted with their weaknesses by employers, which in turn leads them to crime out of frustration, despair, and isolation.

Crimes such as; burglary, theft, etc., in big cities, but also violations related to asylum laws, such as; fraud in public transports have contributed to the increase of economic crimes in Germany.

These offenses are not explicitly linked to severe criminal offenses, although it frequently has been framed like that by various politicians.

Moreover, some data were implemented according to the number of accusations or offenses from police reports. But, not every offense or accusation is a committed crime since migrant-skeptic individuals, influenced by right-wing skeptic parties, tend to overreport refugees

Having said that, drawing conclusions based on the results presented will not reflect the overall picture as “empirical studies for Germany on the 2015 refugee crisis are still rare and use data-ill-suited”. Therefore further research is needed on the issue.

From DW news

Judgement

Drawing conclusions by empirical data would be misplaced since “statistics are only a more or less close but never an exact depiction of reality”. In addition, theoretical foundations are also not evidence-based but rather a collection of already existing theories on the issue, giving researchers, but also, the general audience, a better understanding of the subject.

However, we can argue that recognized refugees who obtained their legal status are more eligible to commit (economic) crimes because of their failure in the labor market due to their language deficits, illiteracy, and a general lack of knowledge.

Nevertheless, bridging these dilemmas is only possible by a proper integration process wherein the migrant learns the language properly and perceives the feeling of self-belonging. With an appropriate integration process of those migrants that arrive, we can prevent future dilemmas since prevention is better than cure.

Author Image
emcavusoglu

18 thoughts on “Rise of crime in Germany by migrants?”

  1. Hello,
    I enjoyed reading your blog post as it gave me information on the specific topic. I like the video as it created a visual for me to be able to engage in the paper. However, you provide information with little hyperlinks. You mentioned that “compels them to commit economic crimes”, my question to you is do you think is it only economic crimes?
    Grace Akerlind

    1. Hey,

      I’m happy that my paper provided you an insight concerning the controversial issue. As I have shown in the post, there is clear evidence that recognized refugees which obtained their legal status for asylum have been involved in various economic crimes, which I actually connect to the fact that; language deficiency and lack of educational basis as well as sociological surroundings have an effect in. Nevertheless, there is no clear evidence that refugees have increased any other criminological discipline such as; rape or general violence. If you are interested and, have time, I would like to suggest to you the paper of Yue Huang & Michael Kvasnicka (2015), which reflects explicit information concerning different criminological disciplines committed by migrants.

  2. Hi Emre! A really interesting and thought-provoking topic you are writing about. For me, that is a typical topic where everyone has an opinion about, but unfortunately, almost nobody knows the facts – well, you do! The visuals you used are really fitting and make reading your post even more enjoyable. However, I noticed that you used quite an academic tone in your entry, making it harder to understand your arguments. Maybe rethink some sentences and try to engage the reader through language. I am particularly interested in the approach on how to prevent immigrants’ failure in the labor market. Besides the required policies that ensure a proper integration process, what can we, as a society, do? I am curious to hear what you think! Hannah 🙂

    1. Hi Hannah!

      I’m glad that you have enjoyed reading my blog, yes indeed, I have indeed used a sense of academic tone within my blog post, but I tried to combine it in between a newspaper and an academic paper, which provides academic arguments in a way wherein the general reader can understand without using ‘google translate’ ;).

      But I’m still glad that you gave me some feedback since improvements are never bad!

      Going back to your question, We as a society can do little if we aren’t the employer ;), but as a society, we can do a lot of things, with giving them the confidence they need with little achievements they have attained in learning the language for instance. Or involving them in events and little communities wherein the person can interact and meet with different people. By letting them interact with other people and letting him engage in various activities, he will improve his language and will engage with the culture more a less.

      These little things can have a big impact on the person wherein he feels the sense of belonging, which is the most important of all!

      And don’t forget, if they succeed, we succeed! not because of our individual initiative only, but also because we do things together.

      1. Hi Emre! Thank you so much for your answer and for giving suggestions on what we can do as a society. Very motivating and nice words 🙂

  3. Hello fellow blogger,
    Quite an academic piece we have here!

    Your headline asks whether the crime rates increased in Germany simultaneously with heavy migration flows (in 2015-16, I expect?). However, you left the reader without an answer!
    In 2020, 21.9 million people had a migrant background, representing 26.7% of the population in Germany. What could be the reasons for the rise of crime rates? Did the crime rates grow only among the newly arrived migrants, or did the rates generally increase within the German people?

    Kindly,
    Sari

    1. Hey!,

      I hope you enjoyed reading my blog post, despite your little doubts ;).
      Yes, my post concerns whether migrants that have entered European soil after Europe’s migration crisis have contributed to criminal crime. I have, nevertheless, mentioned this within the introduction and within the section of empirics 😉

      Returning back to your question, I have frequently explained that there are various reasons (with the support of theories) why refugees that have attained their legal status ”would” engage in criminal crime. One of the theories which I found striking was the theory of regional conditions, which I later supported with empirical prove by different scholars which explained that poor labor prospects, the impediment of financial support, and unemployment could have contributed to the possible motives for migrants to commit criminal crimes.

      These inducements were later confirmed by research, although, as mentioned, “empirical studies for Germany on the 2015 refugee crisis are still rare and use data-ill-suited”. Therefore, giving a proper and concrete answer on whether they have increased criminal crime is not possible, yet, unless further research within the field will follow.

      Lastly, you asked whether (the crime rates grew only among the newly arrived migrants, or did the rates generally increase within the German people?)

      In focussed within my blog post on newly arrived migrants after Europe’s migration crisis, not within the German people ;), within newly arrived migrants which obtained their legal status, there has been indeed a link between economic crime and refugees.

      If you have further questions, I would like to further answer them 😉

      Emre

  4. Hello Emre,
    Thanks for this blog, it is well visualised, with interesting insights on quite a sensitive topic. I am glad you are talking about this issue and providing more theoretical and empirical facts.
    However, I wonder if there are any exact data and / or statistics that indicates the amount of crimes committed by refugees and / or asylum seekers? or it is just the media that is portraying this propaganda in a way that we believe all crimes are committed by refugees and immigrants.
    Also I wanted to know what is your personal opinion and what do you think about this topic? are all crimes committed by refugees?

    Thank you!

    Haroon 🙂

    1. Hey Haroon! 🙂

      I am happy that you acknowledge the importance of the subject!
      Concerning your question, there has been indeed various statistical data and reports which measured the possible crime rates committed by migrants. However, each report of statistical data reflects a different result since each has approached or conducted its research differently!

      Some scholars have categorized different population groups with different crime subcategories, while others have focussed on the actual rates of victimization of natives by foreigners or vice versa.

      Since every conducted research has its own ratio with different criteria, I have not included percentages or exact data. In fact, I have done this consciously because one result of the other does not reflect the actual truth. In addition, as mentioned, “empirical studies for Germany on the 2015 refugee crisis are still rare and use data-ill-suited.

      Thus, therefore, I hope to encourage my audience to fulfill the gap of knowledge which in the future hopefully will give us a concrete answer.

      Going to your last question, no, not all crimes are committed by refugees hahahaah!, although sometimes the media portrays it like that, no? It is not a lie that if one refugee commits a crime that, that crime will be mainstreamed more than, if, a normal German native will commit the same crime.

      It is on us, as normal citizens to evaluate writings, blogs, newspapers because as you all know, not everything is reliable to read!

      Emre 🙂

  5. Hello there! I really enjoy reading your blog because I just wrote a post regarding immigration and crime in Italy. I was thinking, what could be the causes of Germany’s rising crime rate? And, in your opinion, what might the government do to reduce crime rates?

    1. Hey,

      I am happy that you have enjoyed reading my blog post.

      There are actually various reasons on why; Germany’s criminal crime rate has increased by migrants. I have reflected for instance 3 theories that have theorized what the reasons can be. One was for instance that regional conditions and poor labor prospects may have an influence in evoking migrants to commit crimes.

      I would suggest that the German government should center its attention in particular on the integration process when migrants arrive in Germany since preventing future dilemmas is better than curing them ;).

      Within the integration process, migrants that have arrived can learn the language more properly, can interact with other people within the asylum center, and engage in various activities.

      Don’t hesitate to ask other questions :), I will look forward to it!

      Emre

  6. Hi!

    I really enjoyed reading your blog. I think you raised valid and interesting points. I just have one question. You mention how that burglary and theft are common crimes. I was wondering how common crimes such as assault were?

    Kind regards,

    1. Hi Thomas!

      I am happy that you have enjoyed reading my blog! That’s a valid question you just asked me there! As you have read throughout the blog! Recognized refugees have indeed been engaged and involved in economic crimes such as burglary, theft, etc., in big cities! But crimes such as assault have been categorized within the category of violent crime, which does not show that migrants have been engaged in such crimes, and if there is a given percentage concerning that type of crime, it would be limited small.

      If you are more interested in the subject, I can recommend you the conducted research by Maghularia, R. & Uebelmesser, S. (2019), which investigates the contribution of immigrations on various crimes based on panel data!

      If you have further questions I would like to answer it!

      Emre

  7. I seriously love your blog.. Pleasant colors & theme.
    Did you build this website yourself? Please reply back as I’m attempting to create my very own site and want to know where
    you got this from or exactly what the theme is named.
    Cheers!

  8. Good day! This post could not be written any better!
    Reading through this post reminds me of my old room
    mate! He always kept talking about this. I will forward this page
    to him. Fairly certain he will have a good read. Thank you for sharing!

  9. Everything typed made a great deal of sense. However, consider this,
    suppose you wrote a catchier post title? I am not saying your content is not
    good, but suppose you added a title that grabbed a person’s attention? I mean Rise of crime in Germany by migrants?
    | Refugee Immigration to Europe is a little vanilla. You ought to peek at Yahoo’s home page and note
    how they create post headlines to get people to click.
    You might add a related video or a pic or two to get readers excited about everything’ve got to say.

    Just my opinion, it could bring your posts a little livelier.

  10. I am curious to find out what blog system you’re using?
    I’m having some small security issues with my latest site and
    I would like to find something more safeguarded. Do you have any solutions?

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *